Giuseppi's Pizza and Pasta

Giuseppi's has been the island's go-to pizza spot for decades. Classic New York-style pies, house-made pasta, and a stromboli that has its own devoted following. No frills, no pretense — just reliably excellent pizza at fair prices.

Locals order from here on nights when they don't want to cook and don't want to make a production of dinner. The pizza is the real deal. The pasta is made in-house. The stromboli is the sleeper hit on the menu.

If you're feeding a family or a group and want something everyone will love without spending a lot, Giuseppi's is the call.