Italian & Small Plates

Michael Anthony's

Neighborhood Italian Gem with a Gourmet Market

4.9 (1,826 reviews)

Mon–Sat 10am–8:30pm, Lunch 11:30am–2pm, Dinner 4:30pm–8:30pm

$$ · Reservations accepted

Our Local Take

When we're craving an authentic taste of Italy right here on Hilton Head, Michael Anthony's Cafe is our go-to. It's an intimate, chef-driven experience that truly transports you with its focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and meticulously handmade pasta. This isn't just dinner; it's a culinary journey that feels both sophisticated and incredibly welcoming, like dining at a good friend's home, if that friend were a master Italian chef.

What To Order

Handmade Tagliatelle with Bolognese — A rich, slow-cooked meat sauce clinging perfectly to fresh, house-made pasta.

Pan-Seared Scallops with Risotto — Perfectly seared scallops atop creamy, flavorful risotto, showcasing seasonal ingredients.

Osso Buco — Tender, fall-off-the-bone braised veal shank, a true Mediterranean comfort classic.

Menu Highlights

GemelliBaked Ziti BologneseCafe MargheritaFresh House-Made Pasta

Insider Tips

Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season, as this intimate spot fills up quickly.

Don't skip the daily specials; they often feature unique, seasonal ingredients and innovative preparations.

Explore their extensive wine list, which perfectly complements the Mediterranean-Italian flavors, and ask your server for pairing recommendations.

Frequently Asked Questions